THE VBP Blog
New York Managed Long-Term Care and the Future of Value-Based Payments
New eligibility rules and CDPAP restructuring are testing access to community care as New York pauses its MLTC value-based payment program
November 20, 2026 – New York’s managed long-term care system has an important purpose: helping people with chronic illnesses and disabilities receive support in their homes and communities. Its Managed Long-Term Care program organizes services such as home care and adult day care through state-approved plans. For consumers, its value depends on whether that support arrives reliably and reflects how they want to live.
Recent changes put that promise under pressure. New York tightened eligibility for new MLTC applicants in September 2025, consolidated administration of consumer-directed personal assistance, and stopped administering its MLTC-specific value-based payment program in January 2026. These developments raise a connected question: how will the state protect access while holding plans and providers accountable for meaningful outcomes?
How New York’s MLTC System Is Structured
New York’s MLTC has three lines of business: MLTC Partial Capitation (MLTCP), Medicaid Advantage Plus (MAP) and Program for the All-Inclusive Care for the Elderly (PACE).
MLTC Partial Capitation (MLTCP) covers Medicaid community-based long-term care and related services, while Medicare coverage generally remains separate. It is mandatory for dual-eligible individuals who are age 21 and older, receiving CBLTSS for more than 120 days and that meet the Minimum Needs Requirements. It is voluntary for duals aged 18 through 20, or non-duals who are assessed as needing CBLTSS for more than 120 days and meet the Minimum Needs Requirements.
Medicaid Advantage Plus is a plan specifically designed for individuals 18 years of age or older who have both Medicare and Medicaid. The MAP plan works together with a Medicare plan to administer all Medicare, Medicaid, long term care, and drug benefits under one health care organization.
The PACE program is for individuals who are 55 years of age or older who have Medicare and Medicaid or Medicaid only. With a PACE plan, health care and long term care services are provided by a PACE team of doctors, nurses, social workers, and other professionals who help coordinate all the members’ Medicare, Medicaid, long term care, and drug benefits under one plan. However, you must live in a PACE service area to participate.
Those differences matter for accountability. A home care provider can help prevent falls or recognize a developing health problem but has no control over hospital discharge practices or access to physicians. Payment arrangements should recognize the services each organization controls and encourage coordination across them. This goes directly to attribution, which is the core of VBP.
Consider an illustrative partial-capitation dual-eligible member returning home after hospitalization. The MLTC plan coordinates covered home care, while separate Medicare covers the eligible inpatient hospital stay, but a successful transition requires those parties to exchange information and arrange timely support. If home care starts late after discharge, the delay could arise from late notice, a delay in authorization, or an agency staffing gap. A payment measure should reflect which part of the transition each organization can influence. Measuring only the home care provider’s performance could miss a breakdown elsewhere.
New York takes an interesting approach by maintaining multiple approaches to community care. These three models give eligible consumers different ways to organize their care. Some may want to keep their Medicare coverage separate, while others may prefer a plan or care team that coordinates medical and long-term care together. the flexibility is useful, but the practical test is whether they know who will arrange their home care, when it will start, and whom to call if it falls through. That is where coordination matters most: making sure the help a person needs is there when they get home.
How Recent Changes Affect Access to Community Care
Under MLTC Policy 25.04, effective September 1, 2025, new partial-capitation and MAP applicants generally must need community-based LTSS for more than 120 days and at least limited physical assistance with three or more activities of daily living. People with an Alzheimer’s disease or dementia diagnosis can qualify through a different threshold, requiring at least supervision with two or more ADLs.
The policy protects legacy eligibility for qualifying existing members who remain continuously enrolled, but the main concern is what happens to people whose needs are serious but fall below the threshold. An applicant who needs help with fewer ADLs may still face substantial risks living alone. The state should track unmet need and subsequent institutional use among applicants who are denied enrollment because they fall below the new threshold, rather than judge the policy solely by spending or enrollment changes.
Consumer direction faces a different continuity challenge. CDPAP allows eligible consumers to choose and train their personal assistants. On April 1, 2025, New York began its transition to Public Partnerships LLC as the statewide fiscal intermediary responsible for payroll and related administration.
Consumer advocates challenged the transition, and the state reported that approximately 75,000 consumers moved from CDPAP to Medicaid Personal Care Services, a separate Medicaid-funded program. The Engesser litigation and proposed settlement protections addressed additional transition time and notice and hearing rights before benefit termination. The broader lesson is practical: administrative consolidation must be evaluated through service continuity, worker payment and consumers’ ability to retain their chosen assistance.
How MLTC Has Performed for Members
New York publishes an MLTC quality dashboard and regional consumer guides, combining assessment-based performance information with member experience. This creates a useful foundation for comparison, although readers must check the measurement year behind each result.
The 2023 MLTC Member Satisfaction Survey offers encouraging findings. Among respondents, 93% rated their plan excellent or good at helping them remain at home rather than in a nursing home, and 86% reported involvement in care-plan decisions. Home health aides were reported always or usually on time by 93%.
The same survey identifies weaknesses. Overall excellent or good plan ratings fell from 88% in 2021 to 85% in 2023. Only 67% reported complaints or grievances were always or usually handled to their satisfaction, down from 71%. These are respondent experiences, not proof that every member received adequate care, and they predate the recent eligibility and CDPAP changes.
The 2024 External Quality Review report, released in April 2026, examines performance improvement, measure validation, compliance and network adequacy across the three MLTC models. IPRO conducts the external review on behalf of DOH. It is external to the plans, while operating within a state-commissioned oversight process.
New York also strengthened partial-capitation and MAP oversight of contracted social adult day care programs through Policy 25.05, including checks of occupancy, service records and person-centered plans. Consumers can obtain free, independent assistance from ICAN. These safeguards matter, but reporting should ultimately show whether identified problems were corrected and members experienced better services.
How New York’s MLTC Value-Based Payment Approach Is Changing
New York developed payment frameworks that distinguish pay-for-performance from pay-for-reporting. In its 2025 MAP measure set, performance measures included falls with injury, pain, continence and potentially avoidable hospitalizations. Pay-for-reporting rewards data submission; it does not necessarily reward improved outcomes.
The framework also included member ratings of aides, involvement in care planning and aide timeliness. These appeared as Category 2 pay-for-reporting measures, reflecting implementation feasibility concerns. Their inclusion was valuable, although reporting incentives alone offer limited accountability for improving consumer experience.
DOH’s current VBP notice states that it stopped administering MLTC VBP effective January 1, 2026, until further notice, and will not collect MLTC VBP data for measurement year 2026. That announcement does not establish that every plan-provider incentive contract ended, or that ordinary quality oversight disappeared.
Before plans and providers take on more financial risk, they need reliable measures, timely data, and clear rules for which members and outcomes count toward each contract. A measure such as potentially avoidable hospitalizations can reflect decisions made by several organizations. The contract should spell out how those organizations share responsibility and which changes each can reasonably make.
Meanwhile, New York is continuing to refine its broader Medicaid payment policy. Its updated VBP roadmap, effective January 1, 2027, calls for more focused quality measures, clearer data sharing, and arrangements that address identified health disparities. Those changes show where the state is taking Medicaid VBP more broadly. The state has yet to identify them as a replacement for the paused MLTC program.
The pause warrants a clear explanation and a public account of how LTSS outcomes will influence payment going forward. Any future framework should reward adequate support and continuity, with safeguards against achieving savings by reducing necessary care. It’s also important that VBP isn’t solely tied to reporting, rather, the care that consumers are actually receiving.
Advocate’s Perspective
New York has a strong foundation for managed LTSS through community-based services, consumer direction, public quality reporting and independent assistance. Its next phase should focus on preserving access and strengthening accountability. That means monitoring unmet needs among people excluded by new eligibility rules, ensuring administrative changes do not interrupt care, and reporting which problems oversight uncovered, what plans did to correct them, and whether members saw an improvement.. The state should also clarify the future of MLTC value-based payment and involve consumers in designing any replacement. Measures should emphasize choice and control, community participation, reliable personal care and avoidable institutionalization, while recognizing the needs of the people served. For someone relying on assistance to get out of bed, prepare meals or leave home, value is tangible. New York’s reforms should make that support easier to obtain and more dependable.
Onward!
Free E-Book
Paying for Outcomes: The Value-Based Revolution Written by Fady Sahhar
A practical guide for payers, providers, and policymakers shaping the next generation of healthcare delivery.
Now Available for Free
DOWNLOAD NOW
Share This Blog!
Get even more insights on Linkedin & Twitter
About the Author
Fady Sahhar brings over 30 years of senior management experience working with major multinational companies including Sara Lee, Mobil Oil, Tenneco Packaging, Pactiv, Progressive Insurance, Transitions Optical, PPG Industries and Essilor (France).
His corporate responsibilities included new product development, strategic planning, marketing management, and global sales. He has developed a number of global communications networks, launched products in over 45 countries, and managed a number of branded patented products.
About the Co-Author
Mandy Sahhar provides experience in digital marketing, event management, and business development. Her background has allowed her to get in on the ground floor of marketing efforts including website design, content marketing, and trade show planning. Through her modern approach, she focuses on bringing businesses into the new digital age of marketing through unique approaches and focused content creation. With a passion for communications, she can bring a fresh perspective to an ever-changing industry. Mandy has an MBA with a marketing concentration from Canisius College.
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo.